FREE QUOTE - CALL 920-468-5927

HART
  • Products
    • Filling
      • Automatic Lidding
      • Auto-Pouch Assembly Equipment
      • PFC-10 Spouted Pouch Filler
      • HCC Filling Line
      • HPC Filling Line
      • SA-12 Filler
      • Bulk Filling
    • Slice on Slice (SOS)
      • Casting Line
      • 3 x 12 Wrapper
      • 2-,3-, & 4- Stage Stackers
      • 20-ESW IWS Extruder
      • Servo Cutoff
      • Ribbon Loaf Auto Harp Infeed
    • Cutting
      • Natural Cheese Cutters
      • Mozzarella Log Slicer
      • Cutting & Elevating Conveyors
      • Lane Diverter
      • Two-Stage Cutters
      • Vertical Cutters
      • Wheel Cutters
        • Semi-Automatic Wheel Cutters
        • Automatic Wheel Cutters
      • 640 Block / 550 Barrel Cutters
        • 640 AL Cutters
        • 640 HC Cutters
        • 640 Pneumatic Cutters
      • Slab Cutters
      • Ultrasonic Cutters
      • Exact Weight Cutters
      • Dicer
    • Conveyance / Robotics & Product Handling
      • Case Packing
      • Cutting & Elevating Conveyors
      • Lane Diverter
      • Debox & Defoiling
      • Flex Pickers
      • Robotic Palletizing
      • Automated Product Loading
      • Lidding
      • Cheese Wheel Salting, Spicing & Washing
    • Shred Line
      • Retail Cheese Shred Lines
      • Food Service Shred Lines
      • Cutting & Elevating Conveyors
      • Lane Diverter
      • Two-Stage Cutter
      • Slab Cutter
      • 640 HC Cutter
  • Product Videos
  • About Us
    • Meet the Team
    • Upcoming Events
    • History
  • Industry News
  • Contact Us
    • Directions & Nearby Hotels
    • Employment
    • Request Information
  • Store
  • Get a FREE Quote
Home > News > Defending the Good Name of Milk
HART Milk Pouring

Defending the Good Name of Milk

August 27, 2018

News

“An almond doesn’t lactate, I will confess.”

Sometimes, the simplest, most obvious declarations here in Washington also are the most impactful. With this statement, U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Commissioner Scott Gottlieb announced at a policy conference on July 17 that his agency is finally moving toward enforcing its standard of identity for “milk.” This has set off panic among the deep-pocketed marketers of the many plant-based products exploiting that term — including nut beverages — that aren’t (spoiler alert) actually made of milk.

Dr. Gottlieb’s acknowledgment that FDA has for years largely ignored enforcement of its own standards was a welcome development to us, and to all companies dedicated to manufacturing and marketing real dairy products. Even more important than Dr. Gottlieb’s recognition that fake food marketers are abusing his agency’s regulations is the commissioner’s indication the FDA is finally going to take a prescribed course of action to regulate the use of dairy terms on decidedly non-dairy products.

This comes after an intensive effort by NMPF over the past two years to force this issue to the fore within FDA. In the absence of a strong hand — or really, much of any regulation at all — we’ve witnessed a proliferation of plant powders and nut slurries mimicking real milk in a transparent attempt to bask in milk’s healthy halo.

Decades ago, when the primary offender was products marketed as soy “milk,” NMPF warned FDA that if it didn’t circumscribe the use of that term as defined by its existing standards, we’d see a mushrooming of other products also co-opting the word — along with other popular and legally defined dairy terms such as yogurt, cheese, ice cream and butter. And sure enough, as regulators looked the other way, the field has expanded past soy (which is actually decreasing in sales) to things like almonds, quinoa, hemp, potatoes and bananas.

Indeed, this is much more than just a concern regarding fluid milk. The fake food crowd is increasingly trying to peddle products mimicking cheese and yogurt made from the same substrates as the fluid milk imitators, but again containing no real dairy ingredients.

If you thought butter was off limits because there is a clear standard of identity for butter (one actually codified in federal law, not just regulation) and another standard of identity for plant-based substitutes — known as margarine — think again. With sales of real butter increasing and margarine sales tanking, it doesn’t take a marketing genius to figure out where this is headed. Yep, butter substitutes that meet the existing standard of identity of margarine (or even the lesser standard of a product called “vegetable oil spread”) are starting to be re-branded as “vegan butter.” This development alone demonstrates the crass commercialism at play here by the fake food marketers. Their fight to keep stealing dairy’s good name is about nothing more than building market share in any way possible.

As encouraged as we are about Dr. Gottlieb’s proclamations that “we do have a standard of identity [for milk]” and “I do intend to enforce that,” we also have to be prepared that the regulatory course will take time and require a committed dairy community of farmers, processors and others to achieve a satisfactory outcome.

We know that an army of vegans and animal rights activists, working in concert with the marketers of these imitation products, oppose any effort by FDA to enforce the clear and unequivocal dairy standards. The agency will likely solicit public comments to build a legal case for why the existing dairy label standards should finally be consistently applied. It’s sad that regulators should need additional data to support an action that seems obvious and necessary, but that is the reality of the process.

Toward that end, NMPF will work with our members and other like-minded defenders of dairy’s good name to urge FDA to change course. We all need to impress upon the agency how important it is that the current dairy standards of identity are enforced and followed in the future. On July 26, we testified as part of FDA’s effort to modernize food standards, but more voices are needed.

What does the end game look like?

It certainly won’t result in a major hardship for the marketers of the plant-based copycats, as the required labeling changes will be similar to what’s required elsewhere in the world.

Many of the most popular brands of plant-based beverages are also sold in Canada, the United Kingdom and the European Union, in packages that are very similar to those sold here. The only difference is that these brands actually follow the rules against using “milk” as a product term. The United States — although it has the same standards — hasn’t enforced them, which created this Wild West environment of products displaying food names they don’t actually contain.

As we’ve repeatedly told FDA, the reason that this issue matters is that nutrition matters. The term “milk,” regardless of the product using it, conveys that the substance inside the carton is healthy and nutritious.

Real milk always has the same nutritional content, with the only variation being the fat content a consumer decides to choose. Milk is the No. 1 source of nine essential vitamins and minerals in children’s diets, but the imitators lack any consistent profile. Their nutritional content is all over the map, and none deliver the same beneficial nutrients as real milk in each and every glass. That’s why resolving this dispute is a consumer health imperative requiring FDA’s engagement, and not just a squabble between the dairy community and the upstarts wanting to ride on our coattails. FDA has even acknowledged this, announcing on July 26 that it intends to review its standards of identity in relation to potential public health consequences.

While these fake foods have every right to be in the marketplace, they don’t have the right to call themselves something they are not — especially not a food with an existing standard of identity. At the very least, removing the dairy-specific terms from their labels will hopefully help consumers realize that not all “milks” are created equal.

Source: CheeseMarketNews.com

HART at the 2018 Dairy Industry Association Exhibition WI Takes the Title of World’s Largest Cheeseboard

Related Posts

hart-world-champion-cheese-2020

News

2020 World Championship Cheese Contest Now Accepting Entries

hart-design-cheeseexpo-2020-cheese-platter

News

Record 317 Industry Suppliers to Exhibit at CheeseExpo 2020

hart-design-state-of-dairy-industry-cheese-wedge

News

IDFA Weighs in on State of the Dairy Industry with Dairy Foods Magazine

Who We Are

HART Design & Manufacturing is a global leader in the design and construction of standard and customized stainless steel, servo-controlled equipment for use in the food and dairy industry, with an emphasis on process and natural cheese production lines.

Our 40,000 square feet of integrated production facilities, located in Green Bay, Wisconsin, allow us to provide our customers with superior design and engineering, machining, welding, fabricating, mechanical and electrical assembly, testing and programming, all under one roof!

HART Design & Manufacturing uses proven technologies coupled with continual innovation to produce robust, reliable equipment to satisfy our clients’ specific processing or packaging requirements.

HARTHART
HART Design & Manufacturing, Inc.
1940 Radisson Street
Green Bay, WI 54302
920-468-5927
Info@HartDesign.com

Disclaimer & Intellectual Property Statement

Industry & Company News

  • 2020 World Championship Cheese Contest Now Accepting Entries November 28, 2019
  • Record 317 Industry Suppliers to Exhibit at CheeseExpo 2020 November 20, 2019
  • IDFA Weighs in on State of the Dairy Industry with Dairy Foods Magazine November 18, 2019

Let’s Keep in Touch

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter to discover the latest & greatest videos, news and deals!

© HART Design & Manufacturing, Inc. 2019
Website Design, Development, SEO, & Hosting by The BLU Group - Advertising & Marketing